How we work
Every recommendation on this site rests on published research, and a person checks it against its sources before it goes live.
Why it matters: Fitness and nutrition advice is full of confident claims with nothing behind them. You should be able to see where ours come from, and how sure the science is.
Three kinds of pages
- Articles answer why something works and how much of it you need. They're built from peer-reviewed research, and every claim is numbered to its source.
- Guides answer how to do it in real life: your first day at the gym, using a weight machine, reading a food label. Any health claim in a guide links to one of our articles.
- Programs and tools answer what to do this week. Their numbers come from the articles. Their how-to notes come from the guides.
Which research we use
- Strongest evidence first: systematic reviews and meta-analyses (studies that pool the results of many studies), then randomized trials, then large studies that follow people for years.
- Checked at the source: every number is checked against the paper or its abstract. If we couldn't read it, we don't use it.
- Guidelines are context, not proof. Government and professional guidelines, including the Dietary Guidelines for Americans, are one source to weigh. When a guideline departs from the research, we say so plainly. Same standard for every edition and every administration.
- What people believe: each article names the advice readers commonly hear in gyms and online, then says what the research shows.
- Units: imperial first, metric in parentheses.
How sure are we?
Every article ends with a rating:
- Strong: consistent results across meta-analyses or many trials.
- Moderate: several trials or large studies that mostly agree, with gaps.
- Early: few or small studies, or mostly lab or animal work.
- Not supported: tested and not found, or the evidence points the other way.
Between the lines: we state findings plainly in the text. The doubts go in two places, the rating and the "Reality check" line, so you can find them fast.
Keeping it current
- Monthly check: on the 13th of each month, we search for new research on every article's questions.
- A person approves every change before it goes live. Each article shows its "Last reviewed" date.
- The monthly email, sent on the 15th, lists what changed and why.
- Guides are reviewed every year, or sooner when something changes.
Money
- No ads, no ad trackers, no paywall. Articles, guides, programs and tools are free.
- No money from supplement or diet-product makers.
- No endorsements. Guides describe features to look for, not brands, gyms or companies.
- If that ever changes, for example with paid extras or partner links, every paid link will be labeled, and no sponsor will have a say in what an article says.
Recipes
- We link to recipes on free sites and show only their ingredients and nutrition. The instructions stay on the original site.
Challenge something we wrote
Think we got something wrong? Email steve@sciencetofit.com with the page and, if you can, a link to the research. Challenges are reviewed in the monthly check, and accepted corrections are noted on the article.
The bottom line: research first, a person checks it, and the doubts are labeled where you can see them.