The science › Exercise › Cardio and endurance
Thresholds and training zones

Advanced: for experienced endurance athletes.
Training zones built on your own thresholds fit your body better than zones based on a percentage of maximum heart rate.
Why it matters: Two people at the same percentage of maximum heart rate can be working at very different effort levels. Threshold-based zones make easy days truly easy and hard days hard enough.
The big picture: You can estimate your threshold with a 30-minute time trial, and the talk test tracks your first threshold well without any equipment.
What to do with this
- Find your threshold heart rate or pace with a 30-minute solo time trial (see the steps below).
- Use the talk test to check easy days: if you can't speak comfortably in full sentences, you're probably above your first threshold.
- Use the zones as guides, not laws. Heat, fatigue and caffeine shift heart rate.
- Retest every 6 to 8 weeks as fitness changes.
- Beginners: the heart rate zone tool and talk test are enough (see "The cardio dose").
Go deeper
The terms:
- First threshold (LT1, VT1): the effort where blood lactate and breathing first rise above resting levels. Below it is easy, conversational effort.
- Second threshold (LT2, VT2, often just "threshold"): the hardest effort you can hold steadily for a long time, roughly 30 to 60 minutes in trained people.
- Lactate: a byproduct of fast carbohydrate breakdown, measured with a finger-prick test.
- Critical speed or critical power: the boundary between hard but sustainable and unsustainable effort, estimated from two or more all-out tests.
- Maximum heart rate: the highest heart rate you can reach. See "Heart rate zone tool."
What people believe: A percentage of maximum heart rate, such as 70%, means the same effort for everyone.
Percentages vs thresholds:
- A 2020 review concluded that prescribing intensity as a fixed percentage of maximum heart rate or maximum oxygen uptake has little merit for producing consistent responses between people [1].
- The first lactate and ventilatory thresholds had some support for marking the line between moderate and heavy effort. Critical power and critical speed were the best-supported markers for the boundary above that [1].
Estimating your threshold without a lab:
- In 27 competitive runners and triathletes, a 30-minute time trial estimated running speed and heart rate at the lactate threshold without a significant difference from lab testing [2].
- The heart rate estimate was typically within about 8 beats a minute [2].
The talk test:
- A 2018 review found that the point where speaking becomes uncomfortable closely tracks the first ventilatory threshold, and training guided by the talk test produced results similar to heart rate–guided training [3].
Between the lines: Zones from a field test or the talk test are good enough for nearly everyone. Lab testing adds precision, mostly useful for serious competitors.
Reality check: Different methods define thresholds differently, so numbers from one test or watch won't always match another. The time-trial study was in trained runners.
How sure are we: Moderate that threshold-based zones are better than fixed percentages of maximum. Moderate that a 30-minute time trial estimates threshold well in trained runners. Moderate that the talk test tracks the first threshold.
Set your zones
- Warm up for 15 minutes.
- Run (or ride) 30 minutes as hard as you can at an even effort, alone, on a flat route.
- Note your average heart rate for the last 20 minutes, and your average pace or power for the whole 30. These approximate your threshold.
- Set three zones around that heart rate as a starting point:
| Zone | Feel | Heart rate (common starting point) |
|---|---|---|
| 1 Easy | Full sentences | Below about 85% of threshold heart rate, and passes the talk test |
| 2 Moderate | Short phrases | About 85 to 100% of threshold heart rate |
| 3 Hard | A few words | Above threshold heart rate |
- Cross-check zone 1 with the talk test, and adjust if needed.
The zone cutoffs in the table are common coaching practice, not tested rules.
Sources
- Jamnick NA, Pettitt RW, Granata C, Pyne DB, Bishop DJ. An examination and critique of current methods to determine exercise intensity. Sports Medicine. 2020;50(10):1729–1756. doi:10.1007/s40279-020-01322-8
- McGehee JC, Tanner CJ, Houmard JA. A comparison of methods for estimating the lactate threshold. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research. 2005;19(3):553–558.
- Foster C, Porcari JP, Ault S, et al. Exercise prescription when there is no exercise test: the talk test. Kinesiology. 2018;50(Suppl 1):33–48.